Sorry to hear about the tailgating knucklehead, hope you are alright. I am looking at the C90, the Vulcan 1600 nomad and the Vulcan 2000. I am curious as to why you chose the Suzuki C90 over the others available and why are you looking at the Kaw´s now? In regards to your question, I think that if the prices were close on the two bikes (within $1,500.-) I would go for the 2005, more Power, one year model newer, and a warranty.